“Let him without sin, be the first to throw a stone.” – John 8:7
TORONTO – The local press association is not exactly a monastery where vestal virgins live in seclusion, preaching and leading a life of sacrifice and denial. It is figuratively a shelter of men and women who either work in media or have links with them in some capacity.
Humans, not robots, inhabit Philippine Press Club Ontario (PPCO). They interact with other humans and the interaction comes in many ways – physical, verbal, spiritual, mental, etcetera – that only affirms man’s superiority over animals.
In their lifetimes, humans make blunders. It’s in the nature of the species that humans inevitably commit mistakes. But there are some who miscalculate. Others slip unknowingly, some habitually and still others hideously.
The degree of culpability varies from one person to another. There’s no one individual who can be said to be blameless or free of any fault. As Lewis Thomas says: “We are built to make mistakes, coded for error”
PPCO is one organization unlike any other of similar intentions.
There are members who fall into what may be called “square peg in a round hole” – the unknowledgeable kind who dwell in the club to promote themselves and their businesses. Others are there strictly for professional reasons while some use it for their personal and private agendas and as a way of validating their activities which may or may not be above board.
If PPCO is a house, it is built of glasses. Knowing that now, “people who live in glass houses shouldn’t throw stones,” as the saying goes. But the stones keep coming from there, mostly from rats lurking underground that mutate into humans.
In February 2012, Tess Cusipag, my editor and publisher at Balita, submitted my name for membership in PPCO much against my wishes. I wasn’t interested, being a member myself of four regional and worldwide journalist organizations.
The Missouri-based Investigative Reporters and Editors (IRE), for example, helps hone skills in investigative journalism that are very helpful in uncovering criminal activities in the community. So my membership there is fruitful in terms of sharpening knowledge.
Reporters Without Borders, on the other hand, fights censorship, monitors attacks on freedom of information and supports persecuted journalists from its headquarters in France. Membership affords some protection, specially in situations where harassment could turn into physical attacks, as could be my case here in Toronto.
Not to belittle PPCO, but it’s simply out of synch and out of league. Last year when my application for membership was filed, it had 53 members and four applicants. This year when a succession of presidents took over – from Ricky Caluen to Rubi Talavera to the incumbent Hermie Garcia – the number of members had dwindled to 47, seventeen of whom elected Garcia president.
Clearly he lacks popular support, likely because he and his wife’s (Mila Garcia) leftist sympathies are well-known in the community. I have not known this couple from many years of active practice and never crossed them until lately.
While they were engaged in provincial journalism and the communist underground, I was already making headway as a foreign correspondent, first with the Asahi Shimbun, and later on at Hamburg-based Deutsche Presse-Agentur.
Their ideologies have mellowed somewhat I believe, following the collapse of communism, although there are countries still holding out, notably China, Cuba, North Korea, among others. The Garcias’ Philippine Reporter follows the political left but espouses capitalism just as well, a conundrum dictated by needs and convenience.
The couple is still very much involved in underground activities here in Toronto but in a different way like fighting off perceived enemies that could lessen their self-importance in the community. Their past experience with covert activities in central Philippines provides them with knowledge on how to subvert the status quo as it affects them.
In the midst of the discussion last year on amending the PPCO constitution, Hermie Garcia, according to PPCO insiders, circulated a 2005 news video about me which alleged that I was deported from the United States because of another unfounded allegation that accused me of bigamy.
None of it is true, of course. To this day, no proof exists that would affirm the accusations simply because there’s none in the first place. My attackers would not listen to this, however. The news channel and the reporter had refused to air my side knowing my rebuttals would impact their credibility.
Failing in that, I had to publish my answers to every single assertion in that story in my own newspaper, the Philippine Village Voice, in San Diego, California. That and the story that triggered it are neatly bound in a book I self-published in 2005.
A journalist worth his salt would necessarily have to satisfy certain standards in reporting. But Hermie Garcia, covetous of the PPCO presidency, didn’t bother. The video would surely affect my chances of running for PPCO president, assuming that my application has been approved and I already qualified to run.
The idea of fielding my candidacy was nothing serious. It was a test.
Tess Cusipag and some friends had thought about floating the idea just to see how members would react. PPCO was not moving anywhere; its activities were confined to picnics and socials that had no relevance to journalism. Moreover, a left-leaning faction seemed to be calling the shots there to the utter helplessness of other members.
Talk went around mostly in social media and by word of mouth. Every time my test candidacy was told and retold, the story acquired new meaning. For our part, we were watching how the events were unfolding.
At one point, Rose Tijam, then PPCO president and presently vice president, had informed Tess that my application had already been approved and that it was just a matter of making an announcement that I have become a member. It didn’t happen. Along the way, a decision had been reversed.
Knowledgeable PPCO sources tell me how Hermie Garcia orchestrated PPCO to deny my membership, ostensibly based on the issue of morality. The news video that he had earlier circulated had now become the basis for rejecting my application.
That means he, and the others too, believed the video’s allegations without even asking me whether or not it was accurate and truthful.
For more than a year, I labored to find out why PPCO refused me. Not that I was interested; mine was to know the process and the reasons for reaching that decision.
The mainstream press organizations of which I am a card-carrying member for years never have made any attempts to question a member or an applicant for membership if he is of good moral character. Doing so would flush out the hypocrites.
I don’t claim the high moral ground. And neither should Hermie Garcia and wife Mila Garcia. Nor should many PPCO members who lead a life of sin.
In June 1996, for example, after evading being served with a claim for loan repayments, the Ontario Court of Justice ordered the Garcias to pay creditors more than $20,000 for debts they owed.
Should this case reflect on their moral character? If it does – and it is my opinion that it does – officials and member should kick them out of PPCO on the same ground that they refused my membership.
What’s good for the goose is good for the gander. #
